New benefit cap not constructive
New benefit cap ‘a drastic cut to income for people really unable to cut their living costs any further’.
The Work and Pensions Committee has published the written evidence it received in response to its inquiry into the Benefit Cap.
The benefit cap – which limits the total amount of benefit and tax credit income that an out-of-work household can receive, subject to certain exemptions – was reduced from £26,000 a year to £20,000 a year outside London and £23,000 within London.
The lower cap was rolled out nationally over a twelve-week period starting on 7 November last year. Implementation was completed by mid-January 2017.
Benefit Cap caseload statistics for February 2017 were scheduled to be published on 4 May 2017. These would be the first set of official statistics showing the impact of the lower cap.
The government estimates that, in the absence of any ‘behavioural changes’ from claimants, 88,000 households will be affected by the new cap, compared with around 20,000 under the previous policy.
The new cap is not only deepening the impact on households but also spreading it more widely across the country – the proportion of capped households who are outside London is set to increase from three-fifths to four-fifths.
In advance of the first set of official statistics on the lower cap, local authorities have reported to the Work and Pensions Committee that the lower cap is beginning to bite in areas where there had previously been relatively few affected households.
For instance, Newcastle City Council has seen their caseload of affected claimants rise from 72 in March 2016 to 358 in March 2017.
Highland Council told the Committee that by March 2017 the lower cap was affecting 75 households, as against around a dozen previously.
And advisory services are reporting a substantial rise in demand from households affected by the cap – with claimants suffering drastic and abrupt reductions in income and severely constrained in their ability to avoid the impact.
Citizens Advice Scotland told the Work and Pensions Committee of a large rise in requests for benefit-cap related advice since the third quarter of 2016, typically from lone parents and large families.
And among the examples provided by Shelter was that of a mother-of-three in Sunderland who had successfully made arrangements with her private landlord to settle the rent arrears caused by the original cap, but who now potentially faces the threat of eviction again due to a further £180-a-month benefit cut.
The UK poverty charity Turn2Us told the committee of worrying trends reported by their helpline over the last year: “The most worrying trend that is emerging is pregnant women asking the call handler to undertake a benefit check to ascertain what they would be entitled to if they continue with the pregnancy, citing that the outcome will help them to decide whether they continue with the pregnancy or terminate it.”
Halton Housing Trust said that tenants’ initial response had been to apply for additional benefit such as Discretionary Housing Payments or to claim disability benefit that confer exemption from the cap. They said that “Where there are concerns about the lower benefit cap, it does not initially act as an incentive to find work.”
And there are major concerns about the ability of affected households to reduce their housing costs in response to the cap – particularly as many households affected by the lower cap already live in social housing which is typically the cheapest accommodation available.
Shelter said that “nearly 60 per cent of households affected by the lower cap already live in social properties”, and for those who are in private rented accommodation the option of social housing is “increasingly scarce and difficult to access”
London Councils said that the lower cap meant that “it will be increasingly unviable for households to avoid the cap by moving to lower value areas (including areas outside of London) given that housing costs will be more widely unaffordable. [….] the lower rate is likely to bring a new cohort of vulnerable customers into the scope of the cap that may not be work ready but who will be unable to escape it by moving to lower value areas.”
Concerns have also been raised about the effect of the cap on families placed in expensive temporary accommodation by local authorities in fulfilment of their statutory duty to prevent homelessness.
Research by Policy in Practice, a welfare policy consultancy which works in partnership with local authorities, has found that the benefit cap more than doubles the average gap between housing benefit and rent for families in temporary accommodation, from £1,704 per year to £5,520 per year – leaving local authorities to plug the gap.
Croydon alone could face extra costs of £1.1million as a result.
Local authorities can make Discretionary Housing Payments (DHP), funded in large part by allocations from by central government, to help families struggling with their housing costs.
However numerous organisations have expressed concerns about the pressure that the lower cap is placing on Discretionary Housing Payments budgets, particularly in conjunction with the effect of other welfare reforms.
Newcastle City Council and London Councils told the committee that the extra Discretionary Housing Payments funding provided to help mitigate the benefit cap is not proportionate to the rise in demand.
Zacchaeus 2000 Trust said that “The level of DHP funding being made available is clearly insufficient to support those worst affected by the new cap”, while Shelter said that Discretionary Housing Payments can be difficult and slow to access and can come with extra conditions attached, such as a requirement to show engagement with work programmes.
And one of the main purposes of the benefit cap is to encourage claimants to look for work.
But many respondents to the committee’s call for evidence have however raised serious concerns about the appropriateness and effectiveness of the benefit cap as a means of achieving this, given that the vast majority of affected claimants have already been assessed as not being required to seek work as a condition of receiving benefit due to ill-health/disability or caring responsibilities for very young children.
Under the original benefit cap only 13 per cent of those affected were JSA claimants who were formally subject to a requirement to seek work.
Frank Field, chair of the Committee, said: “Once again we see a benefit change purported to push people into work, while the evidence points to the contrary effect.
“Changes that actually did save money and help the ‘strivers’ get into proper, gainful employment would be very welcome, but that is not what we are seeing with new policies like Universal Credit or the lower benefit cap.”
And Karen Buck said: “As the benefit cap starts to bite across Britain it looks from the evidence we’ve seen so far like a drastic cut to income for people who are really unable to cut their living costs any further.
“The evidence does not show us that being plunged further into poverty encourages or helps people to find work, and the vast majority of those hit by this cut are already recognised as unable to work at the moment.
“It is,” she said, “very hard to see any benefit from the benefit cap.”
The inquiry – like so many others – has been discontinued as a consequence of the dissolution of Parliament prior to the General Election on 8 June, but the evidence submitted to the Committee has provided an initial indication of the difficulties faced by claimants, housing providers and local authorities in the first few months of the lower cap’s implementation.











