Mary Beard tackles online abuse
Women have been told to take abuse for millennia, says Mary Beard, and calls for an end to it.
Like any participant preparing to enter a debate, Mary Beard wanted to ensure that she had done her research when she appeared on BBC’s Question Time, in Lincoln’s Drill Hall last month.
She could not have imagined, however, that an exchange with an audience member about the effects of immigration on the small town of Boston in Lincolnshire would provoke the disgusting personal attacks it did.
Beard referred to a report, published by the local council, which casts doubt on the publicly held opinion that the town’s infrastructure is being threatened by immigration.
A Twitter storm immediately ensured – and Beard was placed right at the centre.
Twitter has, as Beard rightly point out, ‘revolutionised’ programmes like Question Time, enabling viewers to engage with the arguments and comments raised, as well as providing a useful gauge of public reaction to key issues.
However, as is well documented, the internet also offers a safe haven for bullies to act anonymously, spouting aggressive and misogynistic bile, and even making death threats, two earlier victims of that being former Conservative MP Louise Mensch – whose children were threatened – and singer Adele.
On a show like Question Time, however, a programme which encourages thought-out debate and analysis, it seems particularly disgusting when the discourse is hijacked and used to attack an individual’s appearance – or worse.
Mary Beard had to face some extremely unpleasant attention in the wake of her television appearance and revealed what had been said in her blog for the Times Literary Supplement (TLS).
‘Why is it’ she wrote, ‘that people think that having a jibe at my surname is actually very interesting: she “is in fact the twin sister of the Tree Beard”, “…I do not know whom Mary Beard is but wyth a name lyke that she surely hath a thyrd teat and a hairy clopper [sic].“‘
In a subsequent appearance on Woman’s Hour, Mary Beard explained that it had been a ‘difficult’ decision to go public about the online abuse because, ‘ “…women are usually told, “If you respond, if you react, you bring it just the kind of publicity it’s been looking for.”
“But I didn’t feel comfortable with that…
“Women are always being told, “shut up and take the abuse because otherwise you’ll make it worse”.
“Women have been told that for millennia, so look, sorry mate, not on!”
The Twitter comments, which Beard described later as ‘feeble jokes about [her] surname’, are not the first to be directed toward her appearance rather than her argument.
Beard, a professor of Classics at Cambridge University, is more widely known for her BBC programme ‘Meet the Romans with Mary Beard’.
In a review of the programme for his column, AA Gill wrote, ‘for someone who looks this closely at the past, it is strange she hasn’t had a closer look at herself before stepping in front of the camera.
‘Beard coos over corpses’ teeth without apparently noticing she is wearing them.
‘The hair is a disaster, the outfit an embarrassment,’ he went on. ‘If you are going to invite yourself into the front rooms of the living, then you need to make an effort.’
Would ‘the hair’ or ‘the outfit’ be as much of an issue if she were a man?
As Alice Arnold rightly points out, when David Starkey made the claim that there was some truth in Enoch Powell’s ‘Rivers of Blood’ speech, the public outcry was based on the rationale, or lack thereof, of his argument – not his unkempt hair or the colour of his shoes.
Still, Beard draws a clear distinction between the comments from Gill and those from the internet trolls.
‘I’m not defending Gill, and there is a sense of continuity between various form of misogyny, but Gill was not commenting anonymously, and it really didn’t have the sexual violence.’
The Spectator columnist Rod Liddle revealed that he was running what he calls a ‘light-hearted competition’ to find “the most stupid woman” to have appeared on Question Time and, suggested Beard.
And as Beard said: It’s interesting that he didn’t have a competition for ‘worst man’ on Question Time.’
Some of the most egregious and malicious abuse was posted on a website called Don’t Start Me Off!, a website for spouting vitriol on a chosen topic that posed as a place to air gripes about current affairs. It named Beard “Twat of the Week”.
The website was moderated by co-owner Richard White. In an act of ‘gobsmacking misogyny’, as Beard called it, one of the posts on the site superimposed her face onto a vagina – an image that White claims he failed to notice.
After Beard named and shamed the website in her blog and subsequent interviews, it was closed down.
The reason given? Because Beard supporters apparently flooded the site with Latin poetry!
Despite this small success and the claim that her 58 years have given her a thick skin, Beard doesn’t entirely dismiss the effects of the horrific and graphic sexual comments made about her.
“It’s a bit like somebody giving you a punch,” she explained.
And, like the rest of us when we have to read troll rubbish, she thought we had moved on.
She doesn’t want the internet to be policed. She knows that unacceptable things will always be posted. “We are still working out the boundaries. The key is [that] we learn to say ‘Hey – that’s not on,’ and to say sorry.”











