Garment-making scandal: not only Asia
European garment workers work long hours for wages that do not meet even their most basic needs.
Earlier this year the Clean Clothes Campaign released a major report that exposed widespread human rights violations in garment factories across Eastern Europe.
The report, “Stitched Up – Poverty wages for garment workers in Eastern Europe and Turkey”, is the result of extensive research, including interviews with over 300 garment workers in 10 countries in the region.
Eastern Europe and Turkey make up a significant production hub for UK and EU27 consumers; approximately half of the garments imported into the EU27 are produced within geographical Europe.
Producing for the likes of Adidas, Hugo Boss and H&M the report concludes that rather than alleviating insecurity, garment work is locking the women and men who make our clothes into a life of poverty.
Western European fashion brands and retailers increasingly exploit post-socialist Europe paying wages set far below subsistence and poverty lines.
In nearly all of the countries researched the gap between the minimum wage and a living wage is larger than it is in Asia, challenging the common perception that the exploitation of garment workers is confined to factories in the Global South.
In the absence of any legal minimum wage, an Adidas worker in Georgia, to take one example, earns EUR5 for an 8-hour day.
Researchers found that despite a long history in garment production and the highly skilled workforce, a significant proportion of workers rely on subsistence agriculture or a second job just to survive.
Across the region the legal minimum wage is only between 14 per cent – in Bulgaria, Ukraine, or Macedonia – and 36 per cent – in Croatia – of a basic living wage.
Hannah Smith, of Labour Behind the Label, said: “This research shows that on our own doorstep, European garment workers are forced to work long hours for wages that do not meet even their most basic of needs.
“Brands like Adidas ..; who shelled out £62 million to sponsor the World Cup, have no excuse for denying the people that make their kit the basic right to a living wage.”
Workers in the region are also hampered by the inability of unions to fight for their rights.
A Croatian unionist said, “[…]unions do not have the opportunity to bargain for higher wages since they have to constantly fight illegal practices such as long-term unpaid overtime and unpaid social contributions or long-term unpaid wages.”
The Clean Clothes Campaign is demanding an end to the myth that sourcing from Europe guarantees decent working conditions.
Brands and retailers have to take clear steps and show a true commitment within their own supply chain in order to ensure all those who work for them, wherever they may live, are paid a living wage.
The campaign group, along with trade unions and workers throughout the region, are calling on European fashion brands to make sure as a first immediate step that workers in the researched region receive a basic net wage of at least 60 per cent of the national average wage.
Buying prices must be calculated on this basis and allow for these wage hikes.
“Stitched Up” is part of a series of reports by the Clean Clothes Campaign that look at the situation of garment workers worldwide and the steps brands must take to pay a living wage.
And their report titled “Tailored Wages UK – Are the big brands paying the people who make our clothes enough to live on?”, takes a close look at what actions top high street brands and retailers are taking to address the problem of poverty wages in the garment industry.
The report profiles 40 companies on the extent to which their actions are having a positive real effect on workers wages in garment factories.
The report finds that whilst half of those surveyed include wording in their codes of conduct saying that wages should be enough to meet workers’ basic needs; only four brands – Inditex, Marks & Spencers, Switcher and Tchibo – are able to demonstrate clear progress towards implementing this – and even they have a long way to go before a living wage is realised for the garment workers producing their clothes.
Click here to see the results.











