London childcare still an issue
Affordable childcare helps parents to remain in work and families to move out of poverty.
The Family and Childcare Trust’s London Childcare Report is the most detailed study to date on childcare in the capital, analysing childcare provision and costs, free childcare places, and whether London boroughs are meeting the childcare needs of working parents.
In the report’s conclusion they write:
We set out to review childcare provision in London and look at the progress made towards addressing some of the problems we highlighted in the 2012 London Childcare Report.
In this we identified the higher costs of childcare in the capital compared with elsewhere in the UK.
There are also significant gaps in provision in many places, and most acutely for parents who have ‘atypical’ employment patterns such as shift-work.
Where these parents are not able to ‘shift-parent’ or use informal childcare support networks, the absence of formal childcare may limit their work options.
Since the publication of the 2012 London Childcare Report there have been some welcome developments at a national and London-wide level.
The cost of childcare has risen up the political agenda and as a result of this debate parents will receive extra help with their childcare costs in 2015 through a new voucher scheme and in 2016 through Universal Credit.
London local authorities and providers have created many new nursery places for two year olds who qualify for free early education.
But at the same time a part-time nursery place for a child under-two costs 28 per cent more than the British average.
There are also some serious gaps in provision which, in some cases, have worsened since 2012.
Gaps in provision for the under twos and disabled children have worsened in the last two years.
Moreover, there has been little progress to provide formal childcare for parents with atypical work patterns or a wider range of activities for 12-14 year olds.
There are other childcare challenges in London. Despite much hard work, some local authorities have had difficulties finding sufficient places for two year old children who qualify for free early education.
There is also a variation in the uptake of free early education.
In 13 London local authorities more than one in ten of three and four year olds missed out on free provision in 2013.
Another challenge in London is the quality of some nurseries, as it is only high quality provision that narrows developmental gaps and helps the most deprived children.
Staff qualifications are strongly associated with quality and too many London children attend nurseries where no staff member is a graduate.
Almost all research about parental employment highlights the importance of flexible and family friendly working in helping parents arrange their childcare.
Legislation now gives workers the right to request flexible work, but for many London workers this right is in name only.
The Government’s most recent Work-life Balance Employee Survey indicated that just a third of workplaces allowed flexi-time where staff could vary their time at work outside core hours.
The same survey showed that 8 per cent of workers had no access to any flexible work arrangement, which rises to 19 per cent where staff have no qualifications.
London’s most disadvantaged working parents are much less likely to have access to flexible work opportunities, usually because they have less power in negotiations with employers.
This year’s report made a number of policy recommendations that address childcare affordability, available and quality, as well as ensuring parents have access to family friendly employment.
These are outlined in the report and its executive summary.
We would like to see providers, London local authorities, the Mayor and national government prioritise childcare for parents with atypical work patterns.
Another priority is to ensure that other gaps in provision are filled.
One of the most pressing recommendations of the 2014 London Childcare Report is for reform to the childcare funding system, which comprises a mixture of supply-side subsidies to providers, mostly to deliver free early education, and demand-side subsidies to parents in the form of tax credits and voucher support.
International evidence suggests that ‘supply-side’ funding where money goes to providers is generally more cost effective than directing funding to parents, as provider funding can be made conditional on meeting quality criteria, thus leading to improvements on early education and childcare.
Channelling subsidies to providers has less potential to be inflationary, whereas demand-side funding to parents is more likely to push up childcare prices, as hard-pressed providers see extra money in parents’ pockets as an opportunity to put up prices.
The Family and Childcare Trust would like to see the Government set up an independent review of childcare funding that examines all options for funding reform, including a shift to supply-side funding.
Throughout the report, we argue that access to good quality childcare makes London a better place to live and work.
High quality early childhood education boosts the later educational achievement of children and narrows the gaps between the most disadvantaged children and the rest of society.
Affordable childcare helps parents to remain in work and families to move out of poverty.
Childcare helps London function as a global city – without it many skilled workers would be forced to leave the labour market.
Investing in high quality and affordable childcare brings benefits for London children, their parents, employers and wider society.
Ultimately, many of our recommendations will require financial investment from the Government.
But we believe that this will pay off.
Even a one per cent increase in maternal employment would result in a net gain to the exchequer of £200 million per year.
This is a powerful argument for investing in childcare provision.
To read the full report, click here.
Please send the link for this report to your London Assembly member and your MP and ask what steps they intend to take to improve this situation. Thanks,











