Women who report rape “fall foul” of criminal justice system
The Guardian discusses the issues surrounding women who report rape and their treatment by the criminal justice system in an article by Afua Hirsch, their legal affairs correspondent.
“It’s hard to believe that the views of a 17th-century jurist could have any place in the modern law on rape”, begins Hirsch.
She then goes on to quote 17th-centrury jurist Matthew Hale’s rule that “[a] husband cannot be guilty of a rape committed by himself upon his lawful wife, for by their mutual consent and contract the wife hath given up herself in this kind unto her husband, which she cannot retract”.
Shockingly this rule remained in law until 1991, when the House of Lords finally conceded that it was “unacceptable.”
Alongside Hirsch’s article, The Guardian publishes the story of Sarah*, as a case study of the mistreatment suffered by women who report rapes by their partners and later withdraw their claims (see WVoN story).
After nine years of abuse, she finally found the courage to dial 999, but one year later she was the one on trial, being told by a judge that she would be sent to prison, while her huband pleaded not guilty and the charges against him were dropped.
After serving 18 days in prison, the woman from Powys in Wales was released, following an appeal after a Judge said there should be “a broad measure of compassion for a woman who had already been victimised.”
Now released from prison she tells the story of her suffering at the hands of her husband, and her disbelief at being prosecuted for “falsely retracting” her rape claims.
In the accompanying article, The Guardian states that this kind of case is “far from isolated,” citing the example of a woman who was six months pregnant when she stood trial for making false rape allegations.
This was in spite of medical evidence which one expert said made it “unlikely” that her injuries were self-inflicted.
Jury prejudice is often cited as a major reason for Britan’s low conviction rate in rape cases, due to the false idea that society is faced with competing and mutually exclusive objectives, on the one hand protecting innocent people from false allegations and on the other protecting victims of rape.
Hirsch makes an additional comment that one third of all female offenders have been the victim of rape at some time in their lives, and says: “The criminal justice system has for centuries been highly effective at sending out one message: it is determined to treat women harshly.”
*All names in this story are pseudonyms











