Numbers of home births falling
Summary of story from The Guardian, 30.1.11
The numbers of women opting for home births have fallen dramatically since the 1960s, according to American research published last July in the medical journal, The Lancet.
This suggested that home birth trebled the risk of neonatal mortality (the death of the baby within a month of birth).
However, their findings provoked a strong backlash, including Professor James Drife of Leeds University, who argued that the original American research was a “mishmash… that wouldn’t have been published in this country.”
Author Sheila Kitzinger suggested that “A powerbase in the US is producing phony research to validate its own role”.
Within the UK, the NHS has attempted to promote home births in recent years, to some effect. NHS maternity statistics suggest that between 2000 and 2008, home births in the UK rose by 54% (compared with a rise in the total number of births of 14%), though since then they have plateaued.
Since 2007, government policy has stated that “women should be offered the choice of planning birth at home”.
And since 2002 when the Welsh Assembly Government launched an initiative to encourage home births, the number of children born in their own homes has doubled.
However, the proportion of home births today remains at 2.7% – compared with 30% in the 1960s.
Writing in the Guardian, Joanna Kavenna suggests that women “have lost confidence in our ability to give birth naturally”: today one in four babies is born by caesarean, up from one in 10 in 1990.
She details her own experience, saying she became fixated by the 0.11% of additional risk described by the Lancet: “In our current creaking superstructure of healthcare, the home-birth debate is laced with words such as “risk” and “patient choice”.
Kavenna argues that the dilemma faced by mothers-to-be is heightened by the fact that the medical profession is divided on the issue: “highly qualified, experienced doctors and researchers will tell them wildly contradictory things.”
Philip Steer, professor of obstetrics at Imperial College School of Medicine, suggests that first-time mothers should be cautious and give birth in hospital:
“The figures for home births are that one in 20 women who eventually have a successful birth will need to be transferred to hospital at some point during the labour. But when you are considering first-time births, that proportion rises to one in four. Transfer is very bad.”
Yet, Lawrence Impey, consultant obstetrician at the John Radcliffe, says there is no reason why first time mothers shouldn’t give birth at home:
“People forget that with home birth women are more relaxed. If you make someone scared and nervous, then you are more likely to have a complication. There’s also the fact that the first labour sets up other labours.”

















Huh? ‘transfer is very bad’? Really?
Unless you happen to go into labour while randomly visiting the hospital, are booked in for induction or have a medical issue that means you have to stay in hospital prior to the birth; don’t all women preparing for a vaginal delivery transfer into hospital during labour? Women are encouraged to stay home as long as they feel comfortable to even when planning to give birth in hospital. They just aren’t emergency transfers; and as most first time mothers transfer for failure to progress or because they decide they want pain relief they also tend not to be emergency transfers either.
Of course emergency transfers are hard to deal with, same as hospital births that don’t go to plan, but not all transfers are emergencies!