subscribe: Posts | Comments

“Free market babies” and reproductive tourism anyone?

0 comments

sick 8599,2074798,00.html#ixzz1O2HM8xbq”>Summary of story from Aljazeera, June 1, 2011

Egg sales, IVF and surrogacy: a growing commercial opportunity or an issue of social justice?

This is just one the questions facing the Indian parliament as they debate the Assisted Reproductive Technologies Regulation Bill 2010.

All countries must strike a balance between reproductive health as a commercial venture and the bio-ethics of reproduction.

As the Indian Parliament considers a new bill designed to reduce restrictions for Indian women to act as surrogates to overseas couples, the debate about reproductive tourism is back on the table.

At the same time, the UK Government is proposing to scrap two of the main reproductive medical regulatory agencies.

One of them – the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) – last month finished a consultation on increasing the level of “expenses” payable for eggs used in IVF.

European law forbids outright payment, but the Authority suggests that increasing “expenses” considerably would not constitute an impermissible inducement. The HFEA is merely “removing disincentives”, not “creating incentives”.

Whilst both Britain and India move closer to a market driven approach to egg donation and surrogacy, in France the bio-ethics of assisted reproduction remain central to the debate.

The French approach still demands that the ethics of egg donation and protection of vulnerable women are central to legislation, though there is increasing pressure for France to move to a more commercial stance.

France, like most European countries, has a problem with reproductive tourism: a yearly shortage of about 700 egg donors sends some couples over the Pyrenees to Spain, where private IVF clinics pay providers more in “expenses” than the UK allows. Even so, the draft bill continues to prohibit payment for eggs.

Critics of French regulation say it is heavy handed, bureaucratic and homophobic. Lesbians are only now able to receive donated eggs and gay men are still prevented from doing so as surrogacy is illegal.

There is also increasing pressure for France to abandon its ethical stance to ensure it does not lag behind in the science race.

As scientific development and consumer demand place pressure on countries like France to take a more free-market approach to reproduction and developing countries find economic opportunities in western couples struggling with fertility, this complicated and emotive debate is sure to continue.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *