Women journalists and celebrity culture
An interesting piece published today in the Belfast Telegraph by journalist Jane Graham has got me thinking.
Graham describes the journalistic moral vacuity behind the recent disgraceful phone hacking of schoolgirl Milly Dowler (may she rest in peace) thus:
I shuddered as I asked myself what would lead a seemingly intelligent and sane man to consider deleting messages on a missing girl’s phone as all in a day’s work. How did it go? Listen to calls from anguished relatives begging Milly to come home, take notes, delete messages, watch TV with a couple of beers, enjoy hard-earned night’s kip.
But she moves on from the expose which has led to the recent meltdown of the News of the World (see WVoN story) to another point which, although not as serious, is still related.
And that is – the increasing disconnection of the popular women’s press from its readers.
What links the two, she argues, is an attitude of careless arrogance and an unquestioning assumption of one’s superior strength and credibility which is now prevalent within the national print media.
Graham links this moral vacuity to that of celebrity female journalists, who are suffering from ‘London glamour-induced slumber’ and cocooned inside ‘a tiny self-celebrating society circle’.
Because of this, the usual fare served up to readers is of the rich, the famous, size zero Londoners to its ‘not rich, not famous, not size 0, not a Londoner’ audience.
Graham says the distance between readers and writers has become so vast that most women’s mags and female-focused pages are incapable of communicating meaningfully with normal women.
Does it matter you ask?
Well yes I think so. Unless I am in a doctor’s waiting room, I do not read magazines that feature celebrities and their weight loss stories. Why? Because after I’ve finished reading I feel my self esteem nose diving – it really is no wonder so many women have high blood pressure when they finally get into see the doctor.
But, more importantly, as Graham points out,
How I’d love to see these journalists shaken from their London glamour-induced slumber. Perhaps then they might offer us more beneficial female role models than the empty, out of touch, self-fixated fillies currently on offer. Yes, we can laugh at their stupid vacuity, but we should remember that the distorted views journalists adopt after too much time inside the bubble can be more dangerous than we once imagined.
However, my question is how much power do female journalists have? Surely they are generally just the employees of the magazine that they write for (unless they’re Rebekah Brooks), and as such, are dictated to by the magazine owner/editor?
If so, is it not the owners and editors of the magazines who are at fault rather than individual female journalists? Or do female journalists have a role to play in subverting the celebrity culture?
What do you think?

















I couldn’t agre with you more. Isometimes wonder whether these magazine writers can be called journalists.
For the most part in quality newspapers, female journalists write intelligent,thought-provoking articles instead of boring, gossipy, celebrity culture rubbish so why can’t magazine journalists attempt to do the same, despite what their editors might mistakenly think their audience want? Why are women being given this crap?
Someone keeps buying it, advertisers keep paying to be in these mags – there is little incentive for them to overhaul a successful formula. Do we get used to it as we grow up and keep on buying the mags, do we see one interesting article or offer and get suckered back into being readers?
It’s amazing, actually, the range of magazines out there and none of them seem to get it right. They all fail at one thing or another, whether it’s the mix of articles or the tone they seem to take of ‘Good for you for trying, even though you’ll never be good enough!’
Thank you both for your comments: I just wonder whether it is public inertia that keeps this kind of celebrity vacuity going? Without any kind of protest from the public, why would anything change? Maybe it is up to us to stop buying them, because once the profit is gone the changes will take place quickly – witness the recent demise of the News of the World – once the advertisers bailed, the paper was doomed. Also, the classic case of the The Sun not being bought by the Liverpool public since the Hillsborough disaster demonstrates that the public can, and do, boycott media when they cross a particular line.
Yes, the public can boycott the media but the Sun has not come crashing down as a result of the Liverpool boycott.
I wonder if we all like to buy vacuous magazines sometimes as a change from the serious reality of life? I know I couldn’t stay with WVoN and the other serious sites if there wasn’t also a Cheezburger Network to provide some laughs.
As much as I don’t like the mags with the endless impossibly thin and flawless edited pictures of models and the make-up tips and the clothing ideas, the ones that really get me ranting are the cheap magazines often at the checkouts in supermarkets, the ones specialising in finding the worst things possible and then writing about them in a gory tabloid fashion. You know the ones – full of ‘true life’ stories about someone surviving this horrific attack or that horrible life. Thoroughly depressing.
It does look like print media in general is undergoing a bit of a change. In a digital age where people are happy to share opinion and talent for free (the lucky few being offered paying work as a result) the magazines are looking a bit outdated. Why would consumers continue to read the same articles every June issue (written in February to be published in March, it seems) about how to ‘get the perfect swimsuit body!’ and ‘flatter your figure!’ by buying whichever pricey suit is in fashion that year? They can go to the blogosphere or the wider net and find articles on exercising how they want to, whether diets are any use, good places to swim, shops that sell clothes they actually *want* to buy, truly one-off and original items in crafting communities, made-to-measure clothes (not forced-to-measure-up bodies), how the changing weather is affecting communities worldwide, good ideas for places to visit on days out (whether single or taking along friends, lovers, families), interesting community projects to get involved with instead of going to yet another slimming club: all available in June when they *want* the info, and all for the price of an internet connection.
Perhaps we should be old-fashioned about this. Let’s write letters to the major women’s magazines. They may not get printed, but I’m assuming that the writers and journalists on these magazines are intelligent women (with a few token men! 😉 and perhaps they’d start a dialogue? It’s their sales figures and livelihoods we’d be talking about, might be worth their while engaging. If letters *do* get published, perhaps we can catch the younger women who are just getting hooked on the ‘gateway mags’ before they grow up and resign themselves to a lifetime subscription to Cosmo?
Hi Halla, thank you for commenting. Yes, I take your point that the mags are sometimes an escape and also that The Sun did not fold because Liverpool said get lost. I think you also make a good point about people being able to surf the net for stuff now, and that the mags are outdated. I suppose I just think that they are part of the ‘background noise’ that is the gutter press media and as such they are quite dangerous – for example every newsagents and supermarket will feature these on their shelves and imprint themselves on our consciousness in a subliminal way. Writing letters is a good idea, maybe we should put together a template for people to use.
I’d like a template like that! Do you think it’s worth targetting the checkout mags or just the ‘serious’ ones like Marie Claire, Cosmo, er… I forget what’s out there now. 😀 UK, US or both? I’d like to see Oprah’s magazine and see whether it’s a good one. I want to say ‘wholesome’ as a descriptor – not in the sense it used to be used, but in the sense of something that is good for us and feeds all the parts of our characters and souls instead of trying to feed us poison about how we’re never good enough. I could go and trawl out a few possible contact addresses from websites.
Perhaps it’s also worth starting a campaign of writing to supermarkets and newsagents/distributors to ask that women’s mags are displayed in plain covers the same as the ‘lad mags’ are now, on the basis that the article titles are reinforcing negative stereotypes in our minds and are really just perpetuating the same unrealistic expectations of women in the minds of men by portraying women, again, as sexualised creatures all the time. That would be more about raising awareness and starting discussion though.
I agree that these things are subliminally damaging – how can we continue to feel even adequate when polished models and celebrities are presented to us all over the place?
I think I’m more frustrated that the Sun didn’t go away than anything else! I wonder how much more it would take to topple it? More and more revelations keep appearing, although I see the Times is coming in for flak too now.
Hi Halla – yes the revelations are coming thick and fast now. Re the template idea – will get back to you.
Hi Halla – could you inbox me at jane.osmond(at)womensviewsonnews.org please?
Really interesting article Jane, and great discussion.
I wonder too about our responsibility as consumers? Bottom line, follow the money – these magazines print this junk because we (I mean as women in society, not necessarily us here) are buying it.
More to the point, we don’t buy the alternatives in even a quarter of the numbers: magazines like Subtext, Bitch, Ms, or Bust?
So we’re back to, why don’t women want to read these magazines in the same numbers that want to buy Cosmo? Is it the availability of these titles ‘on the shelf’? Or is it something else?
Chicken and egg problem in some ways, maybe?
Hi Sarah – thank you for your positive comments! Meanwhile, if I wanted to by the magazines you have just mentioned, would I find them on the magazine shelf in my local co-op? I can’t say I have looked at it very closely in a few years now – I tend to get my reading material online. I also don’t look because I really do not want to see a crotch shot in the Daily Star staring me in the face, or loads of boobs feature on the front of the women’s mags. Re Cosmo – I stopped buying that years ago, mainly due to cost, but also because although it pretended to be a grown-up mag, there were far too many ads and very little content that didn’t focus on fashion or sex. There was the odd feature about women in other countries suffering, but very little ‘feminist’ content – has this changed?