subscribe: Posts | Comments

Slutwalks: marching in hotpants

4 comments

Jane Osmond
WVoN Co-editor

Rebecca Traister, a US writer on politics and gender, has written an interesting piece for the New York Times about the recent Slutwalks, a movement which we at WVoN have been covering extensively.

Traister’s take on the Slutwalks resonates with my opinion. Specifically her irritation that young women are protesting against being seen as sexual beings by, well, parading as sexual beings. Or, as Traister puts it, “marching in hot pants”.

The writers over at Feministing also have some interesting points to make about Traister’s article, not least that it seems only an unsophisticated message will work in getting the media to report on the inequalities that women face.

This is something that I am sure most feminists can identify with – the moment when you are explaining your stance on an issue and suddenly realise that you have to bring in a huge back story about “the oppression of women by the patriarchal capitalist system, yada, yada, yada”, before you can make – to you – a completely obvious point about why what women wear really isn’t the point.

I have had these conversations with women, who do not position themselves as feminists, but will instinctively support events like Slutwalk, but also, perhaps more importantly with men, who do not experience firsthand what it is like to live in a world that is routinely dangerous for women.

This is something that Richard Dawkins (see WVoN story)  illustrated when he said about a woman who felt uncomfortable in an elevator late at night with a man who was hitting on her:

She was probably offended to about the same extent as I am offended if a man gets into an elevator with me chewing gum. But he does me no physical damage and I simply grin and bear it until either I or he gets out of the elevator…No escape? I am now really puzzled. Here’s how you escape from an elevator. You press any one of the buttons conveniently provided.”

Given that very few women have the power to change things (in boardrooms, in government, in law) then the disjunction between the feminist message and the receipt of the message by those in power is a disaster.

Perhaps often the feminist message is slammed down by those in power, because they simply don’t understand it, rather than any evil desire to keep women down.

If so, then the feminist movement needs to consider how to communicate much more clearly both to young women and to men, otherwise it is doomed to a scary uphill battle – possibly dressed in hot pants –  for a long, long, time.

Comments welcome.

  1. Anna Reitman says:

    I was lucky enough to see Katharine Whitehorn read out “Sluts” last year. Truly a defining moment in my development as a journalist.

    Here is her response to the recent “sluts” walks:
    http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2011/jun/05/the-katharine-whitehorn-experience-slut

    For the original article in retrospect:
    http://www.littlebrown.co.uk/assets/pdf/extracts/9781844082391.pdf

    The article was originally published in 1963 in the Observer…and I keep thinking, the more things change….

  2. I am slightly confused by Slutwalk now. The message most seem to be going away with is that we can all walk around in skimpy clothes as much as we want to, dammit. I *thought* the message was that victim-blaming is not on and that clothing choices matter not a jot. There seems to be a sizable group having problems with the word ‘slut’ itself too. So yeah, the protests seem to have become (through the wonders of the newspapers) about women protesting for the right to walk through city streets in their scanties if they want to. Which seems to miss the point slightly.

    • Jane Osmond says:

      Hi Halla, but also makes my point – that the real message either got lost or was not understood by media…or I suppose the media couldn’t be bothered with any subtleties.

      • Absolutely. When they have to fill pages of newsprint to a deadline sometimes even the more intelligent papers seem to take the shortcut to ‘Ooh look, boobs!’ and leave aside the debate at all. The tendency to objectify women is still everywhere it seems, in some countries it leads to demands to cover up and in others to bare all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *