subscribe: Posts | Comments

Study says it is not a woman’s sexiness that makes us feel inferior, but her status

8 comments

According to a  new study by psychologist Norman Li from the Singapore Management School, it’s not a woman’s looks that make other women feel inferior. It’s her status.

“Traditionally, people blame pictures of thin, highly attractive women that appear in the media” for affecting other women’s body image, said  Li.

“This study says it’s being exposed to successful women, not just highly attractive women.”

Previous research had argued that in the race for the best mates, men competed with other men on the basis of status but for women, the competition was strictly in looks.

In a series of tests, Li and student April Smith found that reading profiles of success triggered an urge in heterosexual women and gay men to eat less and try to become thinner.

The opposite was true for heterosexual men and gay women. They showed no change in their eating habits when exposed to stories of competitive, high-status men and women.

Read the full story in The Toronto Star.

  1. Is this a peer reviewed study or just another piece of cod science? I assume it is the former or it wouldn’t be appearing on WVoN.

  2. But wouldn’t it follow that in a culture where women are perceived to be required to be sexually attractive (i.e.; thin) in order to achieve success that reading stories of successful women would lead to women eating less? II’m not sure how they’ve reached their conclusions… particularly as we’re hardly in a society that bombards us with images of successful women on a daily basis.

  3. This is the research link: “Intrasexual competition and eating restriction in heterosexual and homosexual individuals”
    http://www.ehbonline.org/article/S1090-5138(10)00051-6/abstract

    “Restrictive eating attitudes and behaviors have been hypothesized to be related to processes of intrasexual competition. According to this perspective, within-sex competition for status serves the adaptive purpose of attracting mates. As such, status competition salience may lead to concerns of mating desirability. For heterosexual women and gay men, such concerns revolve around appearing youthful and, thus, thinner. Following this logic, we examined how exposure to high-status and competitive (but not thin or highly attractive) same-sex individuals would influence body image and eating attitudes in heterosexual and in gay/lesbian individuals. Results indicated that for heterosexuals, intrasexual competition cues led to greater body image dissatisfaction and more restrictive eating attitudes for women, but not for men. In contrast, for homosexual individuals, intrasexual competition cues led to worse body image and eating attitudes for gay men, but not for lesbian women. These findings support the idea that the ultimate explanation for eating disorders is related to intrasexual competition.”

    As far as my untrained eye can tell, it’s that much-maligned evolutionary psychology. (and Li’s web page shows lots of research about “mating”. )

    Here’s a little more info about how the study was carried out (from New Scientist – the link above is only to the abstract and the full article is subscriber-only.

    “Studies have shown that media images contribute to the development of eating disorders. To understand how, psychologist Norman Li of Singapore Management University and colleagues showed portraits accompanied by character descriptions to 841 volunteers in Austin, Texas. They found that women were less happy with their bodies and more likely to restrict their eating after seeing pictures of competitive women”

    http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20727754.900-success-not-size-0-makes-women-want-to-eat-less.html

    This still doesn’t really tell us anything about how these changes in attitude or behaviour were measured.

    I don’t have the academic chops to critique it in terms of psychology, but from a feminist perspective I would argue that he is seeking a very simplistic explanation for body image problems and eating disorders. He ignores a great deal of feminist analysis about the impact of social expectations of appearance and body shape for women, and the ways in which these expectations are conveyed and conformity with them encouraged/policed.

    But the most outrageous aspect is the specific assertion that competition is the “ultimate explanation” for eating disorders. To claim that he has to have basically ignored the fact that eating disorders are a mental health issue, and so ignored a load of stuff that must be known in terms of patient care and support about the complex reasons and processes behind triggering an eating disorder in someone. Again, this is purely a lay-person’s opinion.

    • That’s really interesting. I find the academic-babble very hard to cut through but the extract from New Scientist is a lot more accessible. It does seem hugely simplistic, given the information available about eating disorders, to say it’s all about competition. And also, I would have thought, hugely insulting to all those suffering from eating disorders. Now sure what earwicga makes of this?

      • Having come back here to check for further comments on this article, I’ve very quickly happened on two other articles that are reports on psychological research that consists of showing pictures to people and then drawing from that unwarrantedly authoritative conclusions about people’s life choices and unconscious motivations.

        I don’t know how familiar you are with feminist critiques of evolutionary psychology, but they are pretty widespread across the feminist blogosphere – if you google “feminism” and “ev-spych” for example, you’ll find a few. Also, I do not know if these different pieces of psychology research in these news stories collected here at WVON would be classed as evolutionary psychology or not, but it seems to me that the line of criticism that they are open to is similar, i.e. they are simplistic, narrowly-focused explanations of human behaviour, given authority by their academic origin, which ignore the obviously complicated mesh of social, emotional, political and historical factors that also influence people. From a feminist perspective it is problematic because this kind of research seems to often focus on gender differences and/or heterosexual relationships – at least those examples which are most widely popularised do – and if one can point to a gender disparity and assert that this is due to biological factors, then one has little incentive to question or attempt to change that disparity.

        If you’ve not read it I really do recommend the book Bad Science by Ben Goldacre – it really gave me a great deal of knowledge and confidence to, as a non-scientist, think critically about science as reported in the media.

        • Thank you again Maria. I’m not at all familiar with evolutionary psychology although am fascinated by psychology generally as a subject. However, I don’t purport to know anything about it. I’m first and foremost a journalist. I’m familiar with Ben Goldacre from some of his articles in the Guardian and must admit I like him very much. I’ll have a look for the book. Given your comment on this story and the one about “why women prefer calm men”, I’m starting to realise just how much poor research there is out there which is passed off as science. We come across a lot of these surveys in the course of publishing stories about women and I think from now on we’ll have to provide a “health warning” with them!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *