UK abortion changes rejected in victory for common sense
Controversial proposals to change UK law to require “independent” abortion counselling have been rejected in a parliamentary debate by 368 to 118 votes.
It is a crushing defeat for Conservative MP, Nadine Dorries, who proposed the changes in an amendment to the Health and Social Care Bill with the support of Labour MP Frank Field (see WVoN story).
Under Dorries’ “pro-choice” plans, charity-run abortion providers such as Bpas and Marie Stopes would have been prevented from providing counselling.
The debate over the amendment was to be given ninety minutes of parliamentary time. Dorries consumed two thirds of that time in an opening address that lasted for 58 minutes.
At one point, Field, her co-sponsor, tried to advise Dorries that she would best help her cause if she stopped speaking.
Field’s advice was ignored. Dorries continued, accusing David Cameron of initially supporting her amendment and former Lib Dem MP, Evan Harris, of blackmailing the deputy prime minister into opposing it.
When Dorries finally stopped speaking, shadow health minister Diane Abbott rose, saying that, though current abortion procedures can be improved, Dorries’ proposal was the wrong way to do it.
The health minister, Anne Milton, then rose to say that the government plans to improve services for woman and ensure that independent counselling is of the highest standards.
Milton said that ministers plan to bring forward new proposals “after consultation”.
Mr Field, whose signature has inexplicably disappeared from the amendment he helped introduce, suggested that Dorries withdraw her changes in light of Milton’s proposal.
Dorries refused, losing the vote by a majority of 250. It was the second parliamentary embarrassment for Dorries today.
The MP had earlier stormed out of the commons chamber during prime minister’s questions after an attempt to pressure the prime minister into letting the deputy prime minister “know who’s boss” backfired.
The prime minister, laughing, told Dorries that he knew she was “extremely frustrated”, leaving the comment open to laughter and sexual innuendo.
Ultimately, he declined to make any serious response.
The sexist retort, Dorries’ overwhelming defeat, and opening debate remarks where she appeared to blame “left-wing” opposition for spoiling her summer have undoubtedly contributed to the most humiliating day of Dorries’ career.












