Magdalene survivor advocacy group queries report
While Justice for Magdalenes (JFM), the survivor advocacy group, has welcomed the interim progress report of Ireland’s Inter-Departmental Committee to establish the facts of the Irish state’s involvement with the Magdalene Laundries, it still has some concerns.
The Minister for Justice, Equality and Defence, Alan Shatter, welcomed the co-operation the committee is receiving from government departments, the religious orders and representative groups of women who were formerly resident in the Laundries (see WVoN story).
The Minister said he was aware of the complexity of the task involved and noted the committee’s intention to conclude their work by mid-2012.
JFM also acknowledges this work, but remains guarded on several key concerns.
Primary among the group’s concerns is the Inter-Departmental Committee’s mandate, which says that the role given by the government to the committee is a fact-finding one.
The committee, the mandate says, ‘is not authorised to consider or make determinations on individual complaints, or to recommend or provide redress in individual cases.
‘The fact-finding role of the committee also means that it will not issue or recommend apologies.’
JFM does accept the committee’s ‘fact-finding’ remit, it said in a recent press release.
It hoped that the Minister for Justice would, as a matter of urgency, move forward the discussions for “the putting in place of a restorative and reconciliation process and the structure that might be utilized to facilitate such process”.
The group was asked by the Minister’s office in August to further develop its proposed “Restorative Justice and Reparations Scheme” and submitted the revised scheme on October 14.
JFM is also concerned by Minister Shatter’s comments in Dail Éireann, the Irish parliament, yesterday that:
“The Government will not pre-empt the work of Senator McAleese’s group (see WVoN story) … When that work is complete, other issues will then be addressed.”
Dr James Smith, of JFM’s Advisory Committee, said that survivors should not be asked to wait for the completion of the committee’s work before the government addresses the issue of pensions or lost wages.
These are legal entitlements, as distinct from compensation for abuse, he pointed out, and many of the women caught up in the atrocious treatment meted out to the Laundry girls (see WVoN coverage) are ageing and elderly and “deserve action on these fronts immediately”.
And, he added, “they deserve an immediate apology.”
Maeve O’Rourke, co-author of JFM’s submission and member of JFM’s Advisory Committee, said:
“The Minister needs to determine a threshold for ‘state involvement with the Magdalene Laundries’, short of the committee’s final report, which will warrant an apology and restorative measures.”
“Both the IHRC [the Irish Human Rights Commission] and UNCAT [the UN Committee Against Torture] accept JFM’s evidence of state complicity. We need to move forward on the areas that will make a difference to the lives of these women in the short term.”
Also of grave concern to JFM is the committee’s intention to exclude data disclosed to them by the religious orders as part of a centralised archive established by the committee.
As the orders represent the relevant ‘data controllers’ under the Data Protection Act, the committee maintains that “all such records will be destroyed and/or returned to the relevant Religious Order upon conclusion of the Committee’s work and publication of its Report”.
JFM committee director and co-founder, Mari Steed, having recently fought for resolution of records control between the HSE and former Sacred Heart Adoption Society, sees a parallel between the two data protection issues.
“Given already existing evidence of state complicity in Magdalene placements and remand of women, it is clear that the state was an ‘actor’ and ‘subcontracted’ care responsibility to the religious orders,” she said.
“As such, they have a mandate to retain and protect all records and must also be deemed data controllers.”
JFM has called on Senator McAleese, the Data Protection Commissioner and Minister Shatter to immediately clarify the situation.












