Controversy over rape scandal ruling in Turkey
Summary of story from Hurriyet Daily News, November 3, 2011
The Turkish Supreme Court of Appeals has come under pressure over a controversial ruling which upheld reduced sentences for the abuse of a 13 year-old girl, on the grounds that she consented to sex.
The girl, known as N.Ç, met female suspects T. and E., also identified only by initials, in 2002.
The two women ‘cajoled’ N.Ç into sexual intercourse with 26 men, including soldiers, civil servants, shopkeepers and teachers, in exchange for money.
And according to a report in BIANet, the perpetrators, who were facing prison sentences of at least five years each according to the law, were only sentenced to prison terms of between one year and eight months and five years.
Justice Minister Sadullah Ergin said the case is controversial because the offenses took place before a 2005 reform of the penal code introduced tougher provisions.
However, the Turkish Bar Association said on Wednesday that even the implementation of old provisions could not justify the reduced sentences, and that to accept that N.Ç willingly allowed herself to be raped is “against the realities of life” and “the letter and spirit of the law which was in effect when the offenses were committed”.
However, Family and Social Policies Minister Fatma Şahin said that the court had not yet made its final decision, and that the media had distorted the issue.
Şahin pledged support to N.Ç., and her lawyers, in all areas in which the government could provide help.
Women’s rights activist Leman Yurtsever, who has acted as mother to N.Ç., said they were planning to take the case to the European Court of Human Rights.
A final appeal is also possible at the Supreme Court of Appeal’s general assembly chamber, which makes definitive rulings.
Turkish president Abdullah Gül agreed with Şahin, commenting on Twitter that the judicial process is not over yet, but that he hopes “a decision will be made that would coincide with the public conscience”.











