subscribe: Posts | Comments

The tide changing for the pinkification of girlhood?

1 comment

Summary of story from the Guardian, December 18, 2011

When two sisters launched an “anti-pink” campaign two years ago to liberate girls from a toy industry dedicated to churning out pretty princesses for girls, they had no idea of the fuss it would cause.

“We got hate mail from all over the world,” says Emma Moore, one half of Pinkstinks, the group she runs with her twin sister, Abi.

“They said things like ‘you must be lesbians, you’re ugly’. The reaction was so extreme you’d think we’d tried to cancel Christmas.”

Notwithstanding the backlash, the sisters have turned out to be at the vanguard of a movement whose time may have come.

When the London toy store Hamleys stopped labelling its floors in blue for boys and pink for girls last week and rearranged toys by type rather than gender, there were loud cheers from those who believe the pre-teen pink-blue divide has gone too far (see WVoN story).

A campaign on Twitter had accused the store of “gender apartheid”, but although Hamleys denies that the initiative was a response to that campaign, the relabelling was claimed as another small victory in the campaign against the “pinkification” of girlhood.

The American writer Peggy Orenstein calls this an example of the “princess industrial complex”, arguing that in the late 1980s marketeers realised that there were bigger sales opportunities if the toy market was divided into two distinct camps.

“Colour didn’t come into the nursery until around 1900 and, when it did, pink was for boys and blue was for girls,” says the author of Cinderella Ate My Daughter: Dispatches from the Front Lines of the New Girlie-Girl Culture (see WVoN story).

“This profound fetishism of pink is very recent and is a market-driven construct. Princess is the only game in town.”

Pinkstinks argues that the toy industry increasingly makes products for girls that centre on being pretty, passive and obsessed with shopping, fashion and makeup.

Its second, smaller campaign successfully challenged Sainsbury’s over the labelling of children’s dressing-up clothes, when doctors’ outfits were labelled as intended for boys and nurses’ and beauticians’ outfits were tagged “girl”. The end point, they say, is a narrowing of girls’ choices and aspirations.

The next campaign for Pinkstinks will tackle the growing market in makeup aimed at young girls.

Coverage has not always been positive, one newspaper branding the Moore sisters “dour and humourless feminists”.

The extreme reaction to the first Pinkstinks campaign led the sisters to question whether they should carry on:

“We don’t make a living from this, we do it in our spare time,” said Moore. What swung it in the end was the steady flow of emails they receive from young girls.

“They make me cry. They say we need to carry on, you’re our voice.” Increasingly, judging by last week, it is one that is being heard.

  1. Well done Emma and Abi Moore for drawing attention to and challenging the pinkification of little girls lives. There is no doubt that the whole princess thing influences girls sense of who they are, where their worth lies, and limits their scope and aspirations. It also feeds into boys sense of superiority and othering of girls: ‘you are just a girl’ etc.

    I have noticed less pink in shops and that clothes for young girls are in a few other colours, not only pink, recently.

    I can only think it must have been the Moore’s sisters campaign that has reversed the tide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *