subscribe: Posts | Comments

The trials and errors of Amanda Knox

11 comments

When reading and writing news stories about women, the language used to communicate the story is often more revealing than the story itself.

It seems impossible to avoid disparaging comments about women, especially so when the story involves a woman accused of committing a crime.

It is easy to find examples of this and there are almost too many to choose from, but this piece will concentrate on Amanda Knox.

Amanda Knox’s story is probably familiar to the majority of you. She was arrested in Italy in 2007, along with her boyfriend at the time, under suspicion of killing her flatmate, Meredith Kercher.

Knox was charged, tried, found guilty and sentenced to 26 years imprisonment. Throughout the process she has protested, stating she is innocent of the crime. Having served three years of her sentence, Knox is currently appealling.

Those are the bare bones of the story, but throughout the past three years, Knox has been scrutinised by the media from evey angle. As you may expect.

The interesting thing about language used in reporting, however, is that it steers you to notice aspects of the people involved in the case you probably wouldn’t have if you’d been presented with an itemised bill of the crime.

A quick search on the net has produced what can only be described as a barrage of accusational headlines pointing in Knox’s direction. Knox has been routinely described as ‘Foxy Knoxy’ and a ‘she-devil’.

The bare bones of the story have been fleshed out with moral assertions before being torn apart by media savagery.

The most ridiculous thing about it is that this obscures the accused, the victim and the case. The woman is tried and found guilty before any process gets underway and whilst all the attention is concentrated on the crime, the victim is lost, entirely unrepresented in this vicious media cycle.

It is often the case that our attention is drawn first to the femaleness of the woman accused of crime.

As the preferred malestream idea of woman is that of peacemaking, loving, caring, placid mother, we, the audience, are encouraged to believe that the accused has already transgressed acceptable boundaries for possessing characteristics (whether circumstantial or actual) which may be criminal.

In their book on motifs of violent women, Caron Gentry and Laura Sjoberg (Mothers, Monsters, Whores) outline that women face character assassination over motherhood and marital status, in their sexual appetite, their public behaviour and any potential psychiatric problems (which are then used as mitigation).

Gentry and Sjoberg argue that violent women are made into victims of their condition (woman). Every aspect of their personal lives, both real and imaginary are laid bare and persecuted.

Never is a woman accused of committing crime truly able to speak for herself.

Exasperations on appropriate femalness are not reserved purely for women accused of crime. These bizarre interplays of woman as criminal and woman as victim achieve nothing aside from perpetuating vindictive motifs of  the moral obligations assumed to be synonymous with femininity.

Read previous WVoN story here.

  1. I am doing lectures with my undergrads at the moment about the demonisation of women offenders in the media, and I am using the Knox case as a prime example. Interesting, and upsetting, stuff.

    • Harri Sutherland-Kay says:

      Sounds very interesting. One of the things that has intrigued me recently is the coverage of her new lawyer – Guilia Bongiorno – who is described as the only woman whom Berlusconi is intimidated by, Italy’s top lawyer, a fierce MP, and pregnant. I don’t think people are quite sure what to make of her involvement in the case yet, but I hope to write something on it as the case progresses.

      You can read the Observer’s story on it at this address http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/21/amanda-knox-appeal-italy-lawyer

  2. Patrick King says:

    It’s about time someone looked at the feminine bias in the case of Amanda Knox. Not that I think you did a splendid job bringing forth all the gender differences involved in this case. Did anybody check into the number of lovers Sollecito or Guede may have had? Perhaps no one cares. Did anyone tell either of the other suspects that they had contracted HIV in order to extract from them a list of their conquests? I cannot understand why the so-called Women’s Rights Movement hasn’t been in Knox’ corner from day one. What do they have a movement for if not to see that women get fair treatment? I suppose had she been black that might have worked to her advantage with that group. Now a day, just having a vagina is not enough.

    • People are looking at it. Many feminists have commented on and criticised the demonisation of Knox by the prosecution and the use of Knox’s sexuality as “evidence”. And, yes, they argued also that the sexual proclivities and histories of the co-accusesd were not discussed in court. In fact, feminists have been campaigning to eradicate this problem of “double deviance” from criminal justice systems for the last 30/40 years but the battle is huge because this practice is deeply entrenched in prosecution practice.

      So you are wrong that the women’s rights movement has done nothing; a lot of this work is done behind the scenes and never even discussed in wider circles.

    • Harri Sutherland-Kay says:

      As tenderhooligan has written, people are looking at it and it has been analysed from the beginning by feminists as language often is. However, the question of Knox as a rich, white American and what that means for the coverage and criticism she receives is an important one. I don’t believe the Women’s movement hasn’t been in Knox’s corner from day one, there has been a sort of confused support, some of which is down to the crime, the trial, a lack of understanding and maybe even Knox herself. Do you know of any cases that we could do a critical review of? It would be a very useful exercise.

  3. You seem more concerned about Amanda Knox being called “Foxy Knoxy” – a nickname she used herself – and a “she-devil” than by the fact that Amanda Knox was involved in the sexual assault, torture and brutal murder of Meredith Kercher. Amanda Knox is not a victim; she is a sadistic sex killer.

    • No one is questioning Knox’s guilt (or innocence). That is not the point. Rather, the issue is around the way the prosecution questioned Knox in court and how they highlighted her sexual history, her sexual predilections, and her “many previous relationships”. None of those factors were or are relevant to the case, and they were not included in the prosecutions of Knox’s co-accused, who are also arguably “sadist sex killers”. So why the difference? Why was the female defendant demonised for her sexuality while the male co-accuseds were not? Why were the sexualities of the co-accused not even mentioned, never mind used to build a case? And why does the exact same thing happen in countless cases every year? Because the problem of “double deviance” is still huge in criminal justice systems throughout the world.

    • Harri Sutherland-Kay says:

      My intention was not to make Knox out to be a victim, but to illustrate how women who commit crime, especially violent crime, are discussed in the media. I think the trial has been dealt with poorly and there are gaping holes in the evidence used against her which are currently being explored by the new team of lawyers.
      This story continues to fascinate for many reasons, for me this is down to the gendered language and attention used against the accused, as Patrick King and tenderhooligan have outlined.

      • @Harri,

        You wrote:

        “I think the trial has been dealt with poorly and there are gaping holes in the evidence used against her which are currently being explored by the new team of lawyers.”

        No new lawyers will be representing Knox and Sollecito at the trial. Amanda Knox’s family have hired Theodore Simon who is not qualified to practise Italian law. Incidentally, Theodore Simon changed his tune regarding Amanda Knox’s guilt after her family hired him.

        There are no gaping holes in the evidence at all. Judge Massei stated that the case against Knox and Sollecito was a “comprehensive and complete picture without gaps and inconsistencies.”

        You have clearly been influenced by the dishonest PR campaign. All these pro-Amanda Knox articles can be traced directly back to one source: Amanda Knox’s parents. They hired David Marriott, a PR consultant, and he has organised countless magazine and newspaper articles and television interviews in attempt to influence the legitimate legal proceedings in Perugia and the general public. I’m not sure you have the common sense and emotional intelligence to realise that you have been manipulated and misinformed by a PR creep.

        The evidence against Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito is overwhelming. They gave completely different accounts of where they were, who they were with and what they were doing on the night of the murder. Neither Knox nor Sollecito have credible alibis despite three attempts each. All the other people who were questioned had one credible alibi that could be verified. Innocent people don’t give multiple conflicting alibis and lie repeatedly to the police.

        The DNA didn’t miraculously deposit itself in the most incriminating of places.

        An abundant amount of Raffaele Sollecito’s DNA was found on Meredith’s bra clasp. Judge Massei pointed to the extremely clear RFU peaks associated with the DNA test, the lowest of which was 30% higher than the RFU test widely used for minimum reliability and the highest of which was more than 200% higher. Of the 17 loci tested in the sample, Sollecito’s profile matched 17 out of 17. Dr. Torricelli for the Kerchers affirmed that the alleles (peaks) in the sample constituted the biological profile of Raffaele Sollecito.

        According to Sollecito’s forensic expert, Professor Vinci, Knox’s DNA was on Meredith’s bra.

        Amanda Knox’s DNA was found on the handle of the double DNA knife and a number of independent forensic experts – Dr. Patrizia Stefanoni, Dr. Renato Biondo and Professor Francesca Torricelli – categorically stated that Meredith’s DNA was on the blade.

        There were five instances of Knox’s DNA mixed with Meredith’s blood in three different locations in the cottage.

        Knox tracked Meredith’s blood into the bathroom, the hallway, her room and Filomena’s room, where the break-in was staged. Knox’s DNA and Meredith’s blood was found mixed together in Filomena’s room, in a bare bloody footprint in the hallway and in three places in the bathroom.

        Rudy Guede’s bloody footprints led straight out of Meredith’s room and out of the house. This means that he didn’t stage the break-in in Filomena’s room or go into the blood-spattered bathroom after Meredith had been stabbed.

        Sollecito left a visible bloody footprint on the blue bathmat in the bathroom. Knox’s and Sollecito’s bare bloody footprints were revealed by luminol in the hallway.

        It’s not a coincidence that the three people – Knox, Sollecito and Guede – who kept telling the police a pack of lies are all implicated by the DNA and forensic evidence.

        Amanda Knox voluntarily admitted that she was involved in Meredith’s murder in her handwritten note to the police on 6 November 2007.

        • Patrick King says:

          You may write as much as you like. There ARE gaping holes in the evidence, too extensively detailed by experts to be dismissed glibly with old stories already refuted.

          The judge’s motivational document is a chain of conjecture lacking the very evidence those conjectures need to make them stand. Knox must be guilty because she took two showers in a 24 hour space? The judge knows nothing of women. Knox and Sollecito lied about having dinner at 11 because they did the dishes at 8? The judge knows nothing of college students. If it didn’t imprison two young people who were clearly not present at the time of the crime, the judge’s document would be very funny.

          If you’re so confident, Mr. Rag, Steve Moore was disappointed that Barbie Nadeau declined his challenge to debate on Amanda Knox’ guilt or innocence on Anderson Cooper’s show recently. Why don’t you challenge him to a debate. I’m sure he’d accept. You would have to show your face on American television, of course, but I suppose they’ll let you keep your sobriquet. Your secret identity, such as it is, could be maintained.

  4. Patrick King says:

    Thank you for your comment, tenderhooligan. I do think it might have been more helpful if the Women’s Rights Movement had been a little more evident in their examination of Amanda Knox’ prosecution. I’ve followed it very closely and believe completely that she was prosecuted entirely because she was an attractive, modern woman, living the life of an attractive modern woman. Even if you read the court’s motivational document, they wouldn’t be able to use the evidence against her in Texas… or London. These prosecutors wanted a hot chick killer and if they didn’t have one they were going to make one. Pictures of her released today have dark circles under her eyes. Her hair is dirty. She looks broken. We’ve all failed Amanda Knox. I blame myself because I didn’t speak up until she was convicted. I just assumed the Italian courts were on the level. I’ll never make that mistake with any court again.

    Harri Sutherland-Kay, yes. I can think of a lot of cases in which accused women have received “different” treatment. The most flagrant is the famous case of the so-called only female serial killer, Aileen Wournos. Wournos was probably psychotic at a very young age but that did not excuse her family from deserting her in the woods at the age of 14. Her family moved the trailer and didn’t tell her where they were going. She was left in a lean to in the woods, having sex with older men for food. The parents of her friends knew what was happening but did not take her in or call authorities. Of the seven murders Wournos was said to have committed, after carefully studying her profile, I would suspect all were in self defense. The greatest crime in the Wournos case was her execution.

    You might also look at the sexual manipulation of Judith Neeley, though in that case I have no doubt of her guilt in a horrible crime, still, her husband was treated much more lightly and he certainly had more to gain from their crimes.

    Karla Homolka was certainly beaten into submission by her psychotic lover, Paul Bernardo. They were Canada’s Ken & Barbie Killers.

    More recently in Florida, Rachel Wade was manipulated into stabbing her girlfriend to death by a psychotic, insecure 22-year-old man. She’s doing 27 years for murder. He’s out looking for more “friends with benefits.”

    The fact that the name, Amanda Knox, finds itself anywhere on this list is a horrible injustice. The girl in the room next door to Knox was murdered by a known burglar, and someone thought it would be a better story if they pinned it on, literally, the girl next door. And that’s what’s happened there… and I’m furious about it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *