subscribe: Posts | Comments

A country without a voice – where are the women directors?

1 comment

Summary of and comment on story from The Guardian, May 10, 2011

After the online and in print discussions about the complete absence of women in the 2010 Cannes Film Festival’s Palme d’Or, four female film-makers are included in this year’s 20-strong list.

It’s an improvement, but still only a fifth of the total. Why?

Charlotte Higgins talks to a range of directors to find out, including Lynne Ramsey, director of Palme d’Or contender ‘We Need to Talk about Kevin’; Sophie Fiennes; Penny Woolcock and Julia Leigh, director of Palme d’Or contender ‘Sleeping Beauty’.

Key issues include confidence, the ability to take criticism, and broader exclusion from the industry based on attitudes to women.

As Lynne Ramsay observes, when male directors are demanding, “they can be seen as artistic and creative and having huge integrity, whereas women can be seen as difficult and problematic.”

But the theory that really touched a nerve for me comes from director Penny Woolcock: “Women have children, and I don’t think it’s any more complicated than that.”

“You find that women directors either had children very young, like me … or are childless, or can afford childcare and don’t mind not seeing their children for long periods of time.”

Penny Woolcock’s comments are recognisable fare in any industry that excludes women at senior levels, and the demands of being a director may well force an impossible choice for many women pressed to choose between being a mother or a worker – plus ca change.

As ever, what really annoys me about this is the self-evident, but often overlooked fact that – drumroll  please – men have children too.

Yes, I know, it’s earth shattering.

The problem, as we all know, is not having the children, it is looking after them that counts when it comes to a successful career.

And that’s where women directors – like women chief executives, women managers and most other working mothers – always come unstuck.

Despite the fact that we can put a human being on the moon, we still cannot organise our labour market so that adults – of both sexes –  ultimately do not have to choose between being workers and being parents.

And until we deal with that central fact, the gender imbalance in directing will continue.

As Lynne Ramsey so expressively points out: “(It’s) a bit like a country not being filmed – and that country not having a voice. It really does matter.”

  1. Kashan says:

    I am a film school graduate and have worked in the small industry here in South Africa. I find that what it really comes down to is not being taken seriously. Even as an editor/motion graphics artist or cinematographer, the fields are seen as too technical for the feeble female mind. It drives me batty. I used to work as the pro apps expert at an iStore here in Johannesburg and the amount of sexism I encountered was insane. I would approach a customer looking at the movie software or graphics software and they would literally walk away form me and go and speak to a male colleague who knew less then me (as they were just regular staff). The best part being that the male colleague would often bring the customer back to me as he was unable to advise on photoshop or final cut pro. In a director or producer’s position there’s always the issue of men not wanting to listen to a women in power. It really an uphill battle as women in the film industry. I hope to one day direct and write my one feature film and show everyone here that a women is more then capable of being technically, logistically, creatively and managerially in charge.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *