subscribe: Posts | Comments

Long Island killer shows vulnerability of sex workers

2 comments

Summary of and comment on story from The Guardian, April 11, 2011

The victims of the Long Island serial killer are a symptom of the “social economy of violence against sex workers”, writes Melissa Gira Grant.

In this thought-provoking article, Gira Grant uses the Long Island case as the starting point for making a broader argument about the dangers of criminalising prostitution.

This includes the damaging treatment experienced by many prostitutes at the hands of the police, prompting the question: how can the police simultaneously protect prostitutes while they are also tasked with prosecuting them?

“…we must also accept why sex workers are reluctant to seek protection from the same people who are charged with arresting them.”

In a study of New York City street-based prostitution, conducted by the Sex Workers’ Project at the Urban Justice Centre, sex workers reported that police didn’t take their reports of violence seriously.

Some were told that violence is what they should expect.

About 27 per cent of those surveyed had experienced violence at the hands of the police themselves.

Given early suspicions that the Long Island serial killer may himself be a former law enforcement official, this should be seen as very worrying indeed.

This article raises issues that deserve attention, whatever our personal views on prostitution. Not least that in considering the broader issues of whether we want to end the selling of sex, primary in our minds should be the fact that the lives of so many women hang in the balance of our various moral crusades.

As feminists, the real-world impact on these women should be our primary focus.

  1. Kashan says:

    Oooh how disgusting to say that violence is what a prostitute should expect and therefore nothing should be done about it really makes me see red. Of course the profession is one on the fringes and makes them vulnerable but does that mean because they do something demeaning they are fair game to be beaten and killed by men? I don’t understand this psyche. Its allowing men to not only buy sex but giving them the right to abuse the person providing them with that service. There is something so wrong with this world.

    • Fringo says:

      I hate to correct you Kashan, but in this case there is nothing wrong with this world, it’s actually just the prostitution laws of the United States that are really wrong. The article by Melissa Gira Grant is not at all controversial. It is true what she says. But I guess in a country that uses the Bible as the only source of morality, Grant’s argument will simply be ignored.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *