Australia’s ‘refugee solution’ could see pregnant women caged and caned
Summary of stories from the BBC, Reuters, AdelaideNow and The Australian, May 25, 2011
The UN human rights commissioner Navi Pillay has launched a scathing attack on Australia’s policy towards “boat people”.
“I come from South Africa and lived under this, and am every way attuned to seeing racial discrimination” Ms Pillay, a former anti-apartheid campaigner and international criminal court judge, told reporters at the end of a six-day visit.
“There is a racial discriminatory element here which I see as rather inhumane treatment of people, judged by their differences, racial, colour or religions,” she said.
Navi Pillay said Australia’s policy of mandatory detention towards asylum seekers was in breach of its international obligations and had cast a shadow over its human rights record.
“…these people have come here for a reason,” she pointed out. “They’ve run away from conflict and it is why they have taken such risks to get here.”
Ms Pillay also said the government’s plan for an asylum-seeker swap with Malaysia “violates refugee law”.
“You cannot send individuals to a country that has not ratified the torture conventions on refugees. Australians or people who uphold refugee standards internationally should not collaborate with these types of schemes.”
Under an agreement with Malaysia, yet to be ratified, up to 800 asylum-seekers will be sent to Malaysia ‘for processing’ over the next four years. In exchange, Canberra will accept up to 4000 refugees from Malaysia.
Living conditions at refugee camps in Malaysia have also been condemned as crowded and unhygienic, with some inmates reported to have died from disease spread by rats.
And asylum seekers shipped overseas under the proposed “Malaysian solution” face the prospect of caning if they step out of line while in detention.
Malaysia flogs up to 6000 detainees a year for immigration offences, using a rattan cane that causes visible injuries and scarring – and guards can punish children in this way.
When pressed on whether international laws would be observed in order to prevent canings and the caging of pregnant women, children and unaccompanied minors, a spokesman for Australia’s Immigration Minister Chris Bowen said negotiations were ongoing.











