English women’s equal pay case heading for Supreme Court
Summary of story from The Guardian, September 1, 2011
An equal pay test case being bought by dinner ladies and care workers against Sheffield city council in England is to be heard next month.
The three-day hearing before five justices in mid-October is the first time the supreme court – established two years ago – has looked at the issue of equal pay, an area complicated by the existence of contradictory legal precedents.
The outcome could affect wages paid to workers, particularly in local authorities and the NHS where some specialised roles – such as road sweepers or carers – have traditionally been performed almost exclusively by separate groups of men or women.
The trade union Unison, which is supporting the Sheffield employees, said it had up to 40,000 cases that could be affected by the court’s ruling.
The Sheffield council case, Gibson and others v Sheffield city council, started in an employment tribunal and has been working its way up the appeals process.
The court of appeal last year found for the dinner ladies and carers, and held that the men were being paid between 33.3% and 38% more than women for occupations that the council agreed were comparable.
Ben Patrick, Unison’s in-house solicitor who is preparing the case for next month’s hearing, said: “The central issue is whether the council should be required to justify differences in pay.
“It’s an indirect discrimination argument based on statistical comparisons. The question in the supreme court is whether given a statistical case of discriminatory pay the employer is required to objectively justify the differences in pay between men and women”.











