Indonesian health guidelines may encourage FGM/C
Summary of story from IRIN, September 1, 2011
Guidelines on how to perform female genital mutilation/cutting (FGM/C) issued by the Indonesian Ministry of Health recently could cause an increase in the practice, medical experts and rights groups fear.
“This will give doctors a new motivation to circumcise [girls] because now they can say the Ministry of Health approves of this, and the Indonesian Ulamas’ Council approves of it,” Jurnalis Uddin, a doctor and lecturer at Yarsi University in Jakarta, said.
Though FGM/C was banned in 2006, two of Indonesia’s Muslim organizations ultimately condone the practice, advising people “not to cut too much”. As a result, many continue to perform the procedure.
By directing health professionals not to cut a girl’s genitals but to “scrape the skin covering the clitoris, without injuring the clitoris”, the Ministry of Health stands by regulations issued in June to ensure a medically safe form of FGM/C.
The procedure is typically done at birth, or before a girl is five years old and in the past was often performed by local healers, called dukun, or by birth attendants.
Traditionally, it was mostly ‘symbolic‘ with a small cut on the clitoris, or involved rubbing the clitoris with tumeric root, making it less invasive than other types of FGM/C.
However, Mr Uddin said there was a now trend toward more extensive cutting of the clitoris.
Dozens of Indonesian and human rights groups continue to call for the Ministry to revoke the guidelines (see WVoN story).
“This gives a justification for health practitioners to damage women’s bodies,” said Frenia Nababan, spokeswoman for the Indonesian Family Planning Association.
“We fear it will increase control of women’s bodies by the state and religious groups,” she added.
















My grandfather would say “, Frickin’ Idjuts!”
I’d agree with my grandfather also.
Heck, male circumcision is just about as terrible.
No it isn’t. For one thing it depends on what sort of FGM/C is being discussed. Correct me if I’m misinformed but I don’t recall hearing of the country where boys have parts of their penises – not only foreskins – removed as part of circumcision?
It’s removing a part of the male physical anatomy, it cuts down on sensitivity by up to 60%. So I can sure as heck tell you that it is
quite terrible in it’s own right.
Have you had your foreskin cut? Probably not. My soon to be born son will NOT be cut. It isn’t acceptable to have a knife down that way. Life or death maybe, but simply because of tradition, posh and quite annoying.
Glad to hear it. Now please stop trying to make this about the poor men. I am not going to debate with you who has it worse because that will just take us further away from the topic of discussion. Go and do some reading on FGM and then come back and tell me about how reduced sensitivity is the Worst Thing Ever(tm).
Alright, i get it now. Anything I or any guy says, that doesn’t fall in line with your “narrative” is automatically wrong. Cool beans.
Female AND male genital mutilation both fall under the ideal of being horrific. Goodness, please stop baiting me.
No, I see – if I don’t automatically agree with you then I am wrong. I am not baiting you, I am asking you to inform yourself. Male circumcision is not the same as FGM, please go and do the reading. Stop trying to make it about the men, accept that some things aren’t. Also stop making sweeping generalisations.
I didn’t say they were the same lady, I simply said they were both horrid. Not everything revolves around either sex, but when you completely remove something from being valid from an argument you lose credibility.
I’m QUITE aware of this type of mutilation. It’s a horrible thing, it removes one of the pleasure centers of the female anatomy, in order to promote a general social view of harmony imposed by older African and East-Asian societies on women. Helping to keep them in line and such. Again, you assume ignorance, when I’m pushing a point. I’m well informed about many things lady, don’t assume ignorance when I simply was pointing out another side to the story.
Who were the same lady?
I can see you are informed, I’m glad of that. I have to assume ignorance when no knowledge is displayed – now I know better.
Male circumcision is still not the other side of this story. Help those campaigning against FGM and then maybe I will have a little more time for the campaign against unnecessary male circumcision. It is not my priority and I don’t see them as equally bad things – which is the point *I’m* pushing.