subscribe: Posts | Comments

Petitions challenge blue-pink divide

2 comments

Fighting the gender bias in toys.

More than 25,000 people have signed a petition calling for a toy manufacturer to produce and market a child’s play oven in a gender neutral way.

The petition was started by 13-year-old McKenna Pope of New Jersery who wanted to buy an oven for her four-year-old brother for Christmas but was appalled to find the packaging was either pink or purple, and this put her off buying the item for him.

She appeared on CNN to promote her campaign saying: “I’m sure there are a lot of kids out there like my brother who want Easy-Bake ovens but don’t ask for them because they’re told they’re not supposed to want them,” she said.

“There’s a lot of toys specifically marketed towards boys and girls, but guys need to learn to cook and take care of children, too.”

Hasbro, who make the toy, have so far not responded.

It follows a similar petition which has attracted 2,000 respondents, set up by Carolyn Danckaert in Washington DC who started her petition after shopping for presents for her four young nieces.

‘When walking into a Toys R Us store or opening their catalogue, it’s instantly clear to kids that science, building, vehicles, and superheroes are the purview of boys while girls’ toys options are limited dolls, crafts, beauty supplies, and ofcourse princess paraphenalia,’ she writes.

When WVoN contacted Toys R Us, Kathleen Waugh, vice-president of Toys R Us corporate communications, denied there was a gender divide in their stores.

She said: “At Toys R Us, we do not merchandise, or promote in marketing vehicles, toys by gender.

“Toys are merchandised by product category, so customers can easily see the breadth of assortment.

“All learning toys, for example, from a variety of manufacturers, are merchandised together.

“The same is true for all categories, including sports toys, pre-school toys, construction sets, bikes, dolls, arts and crafts, action figures, musical instruments and more.”

In Sweden, consumer pressure led to Toys R Us producing a catalogue for that country showing boys baking and girls playing with ‘boys toys’.

In an article entitled ‘Let toys be toys’ WVoN co-editor Jem McCarron looked into finding stereotyping in various British toy stores and departments, and has taken to searching for individual items online.

She wrote: “The associated marketing to parents begins before you even give birth via the ‘boys’ and ‘girls’ sections of Mothercare and the like but the children become direct targets frighteningly early.”

A very interesting article on Policymic looks at whether gender neutrality leads to gender equality.

It points out that Mattel has introduced a construction set for girls but fails to comment that the manufacturer has dressed this up in a Barbie brand Mega Bloks Barbie Build and Style.

In other words, it has been pinky-fied and become a mansion which every future WAG or princess should aspire to.

But British store Harrod’s re-opened its toy department organised by themes rather than gender this year.

The Guardian reported that Matt Smith, of Shed Design, lead designer of the new-look department, said that the six zones it contains are “deliberately non-gender-specific, because we felt that was an antiquated way of looking at toys.

“I think increasingly kids are playing with an array of different toys and we wanted to give that balance.”

Harrods is following in the footsteps of London’s Hamley’s toy shop, which last year changed its layout away from separating boy toys from girls toys.

Dr Laura Nelson, who set up the Breakthrough campaign to challenge gender stereotyping, and specifically targeted Hamley’s, told The Guardian: “Until all toys and the shop layouts are completely gender-neutral, there will always be pressure on girls and boys to pursue the route in life consistent with their stereotype.”

  1. There is also a new UK based campaign on this issue called Let Toys Be Toys – if you want to tell retailers in the UK and Ireland to stop segregating toys please do visit the website, sign the petition and join the conversation on Facebook.

    We will be delivering the petition to the worst offenders – we found Wilkinsons,, TK Maxx, Asda and Tesco were particularly bad in our survey.

  2. Good point about the easy bake oven:
    We rob our boys if we don’t teach them how to clean, repair torn jeans or cook with basic nutrition.

    Overall in America, we live in an economy where people under 50 don’t know the names of some of the vegetables in the store or how to cook them. Our latch-key kids live on food-like substances that do not really meet their IQ an physical development requirements. Our throw-away society has taught the younger generation to to simply replace whatever is broken instead of repairing it. Not just object maintenance–but our bodies and prevention too.

    We rob our girls if we don’t teach them how to maintain their cars and get familiar with what’s under the hood. We all need basic education in the areas of relationship, economics in the home and perhaps our churches could catch on the to need if our schools can’t do this. Remember funding (not so much for sports) for domestic education is limited to our education system in these areas in most cases.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *