Disgust after sexism at university debate
‘We were booed because we were women’, and then ‘no one on the committee would take any action’.
Students at Glasgow University have come out in protest after female speakers were heckled with sexist abuse at Glasgow University Union’s annual inter-university Ancients Debating Championship last week.
Guest speakers Rebecca Meredith, from Cambridge University, and Marlena Valles, from Edinburgh University, reached the finals of the Championship, only to be faced with sexist heckling from male spectators.
“Unlike the other six individuals in the final, we were booed, heckled with ‘shame woman’ and exposed to sexual comments and queries of “what qualifications does a woman possibly have to be here”‘ Rebecca Meredith wrote in a Huffington Post article.
“None of the male speakers faced the same treatment.
“After the debate, a member of this group shouted “get that woman out of my chamber” as my [debating] partner Marlena passed”.
When female students objected to the treatment of Meredith and Valles, one was called a “frigid bitch”.
Others were told by the organisers of the tournament and Glasgow University Union (GUU) committee members to sit down and not “cause trouble”.
Meredith writes that “I myself confronted one of the male members concerned, and the GUU committee, only to be told that it was “to be expected” and “par for the course” that women would be booed in the GUU chamber”.
And, she wrote, the committee ‘accepted we were booed because we were women, not for any other reason, but refused to take action against their members’.
Meredith, who has been ranked one of the top 20 speakers in the world, described the experience as “one of the most unpleasant incidents of my life”.
Anger over the two women’s treatment led the Glasgow University Feminist Society to organise a rally protesting this incident as well as “a long line of chauvinistic behaviour” by the GUU.
Originally a men-only union, the GUU was integrated in 1980, despite 139 of its members voting against women being allowed to join.
Perhaps most depressingly, the ‘139 Club’ was later formed to ‘honour’ those who voted for it to remain a men-only union, and held annual dinners on the anniversary of the vote to ‘celebrate’ the 139 dissenters. The dinners were only barred from the campus in 2011.
Two members of the GUU are now facing disciplinary hearings after the incident at the Debating Championship, and a university spokesman has said “The university cannot and will not tolerate abusive, threatening or sexist behaviour.
“The principal has written to the two women speakers to apologise … an investigation by the GUU is now ongoing.”
Female students at the University of Glasgow are now coming out about their experiences of abuse from GUU members: from the all too common groping of female body parts to the fear of rape.
And Caroline Moore, a Philosophy student at Glasgow, has started a petition demanding the GUU commits to ‘zero tolerance on misogyny’.
The petition calls on the GUU to “denounce the actions of these members and … to demonstrate their commitment to a sexism-free GUU by undertaking a gender equality training session.”
Five Glasgow University societies have also written a public letter to the GUU stating that they will break their affiliation with the Union until those responsible for the heckling are appropriately disciplined.
The Cambridge Union has ‘promised not to send any of its debaters to the union until sexism has been dealt with’.
In a statement to WVoN, Caroline Moore said “The incident at the Ancients embodies an entire culture of misogyny that has gone on far too long.
“This is our opportunity to change these damaging attitudes and send the message to students of the past, present, and future: that sexism does not belong in our union.”
















Makes me ashamed to be an alumni. Yobs in frock coats….. (or rugger gear).
This has now been posted on GUU facebook page: Statement by Glasgow University Union, From Gavin Tulloch, President
15/3/13
As the newly elected President of the Glasgow University Union and on behalf of the GUU Board of Management, I am deeply appalled at the recent allegations of discrimination at our Union. We want to be unequivocal – our Union does not and will not tolerate prejudice, however it is manifested.
The Board is committed to robustly and comprehensively investigating all complaints we receive and we will ensure that where action is required, it will be taken without fear or favour.
We have already decided to commission an independent review into the culture within the GUU to ensure that we provide a welcoming and safe environment for all our members and guests. This review will not prejudice the ongoing investigations but will engage and consult with all interested parties and will work with them to address any and all concerns. Where there are lessons to be learned, we will learn, and where change is required, we will change.
This process of change has already begun. We will be working closely with the University of Glasgow on equality and diversity training and this week the Board has decided to suspend all single sex dinners with immediate effect. We have also embarked on consultations with a range of cross-campus societies in conjunction with the Students’ Representative Council. We will take on board, with a view to implementing, any positive suggestions that emerge from those consultations to ensure that any unacceptable behaviour is eliminated.
We will also review how our members and their guests are encouraged to draw unacceptable behaviour to the attention of the Board of Management, and we will make clear to our members, our users and our staff that they also have recourse to the University’s Senate Office in instances of unacceptable conduct. We will work closely with the University of Glasgow to foster an environment of inclusivity and mutual respect, where any actions incompatible with these values will not be tolerated.
Understandably, the University of Glasgow is extremely concerned at the allegations that have been made and is conducting its own investigation into these. We support the university’s investigation and will assist in every possible way. We are extending the period of our own investigation to allow the university to conclude its process. That will give us the most complete picture to allow us to progress in the fairest possible manner.
The allegations that have been reported in recent days have been deeply upsetting for all involved, as they do not reflect the views or experience of the vast majority of our members. As the incoming President I am committed, along with the Board of Management, to listening, learning and acting, and we will work hard to rebuild the trust that we have previously enjoyed with our members and our affiliates. Let us restate: Glasgow University Union does not and will not tolerate discrimination.
If any member, past or present, any visitor to our union or other student within the university, or from further afield wishes to raise any issues with the Board of Management, I encourage them to contact me directly. We will listen, and any comments and experiences will help us learn and better serve the needs of our members and guests in future.
Gavin Tulloch
President
Glasgow University Union
‘The GUU has issued an official apology and announced that the Union will be launching an investigation.
But it has also been announced that disciplinary action will only be taken against two of the perpetrators because of a “lack of evidence” against them, despite eyewitness accounts of the incident.
This is a pretty lacklustre response on the part of the GUU to such a serious incident.’ from http://www.studentnewspaper.org/glasgow-union-must-challenge-its-sexism/