Christian union bans women speaking at meetings
Women banned from speaking at meetings sparks discrimination debate.
Once upon a time there was a Christian Union at a British University which couldn’t decide whether women were equal to men or not.
As openings go, it may not be the most traditional, but the views of the group at Bristol University certainly appear to be, and it’s a story with at least as many twists and turns as your average fairy tale.
Last week, it was reported that Bristol University Christian Union (BUCU) had banned women from speaking in their weekly meetings or on weekends away, unless their husbands were present.
An email from BUCU president Matt Oliver was at the centre of the furore, referencing the ‘difficult issue’ for some men who felt forced to take religious instruction from a female.
Unsurprisingly, when news of the email got out, it was met with widespread condemnation, including from the university’s own Student Union’s Welfare and Equality committee.
Vice President, Alessandra Berti said: “We have been made aware of a communication from the University of Bristol Christian Union, and we would like to assure our members and the general public that UBU and the full-time elected officers are investigating the issue further,” she said.
“In particular we will be making certain that our Equality Policy is properly adhered to in all cases.”
Subsequently, a u-turn on the part of the Christian Union was reported, with an official statement from the group quoting: “Bristol University Christian Union (BUCU) deplores the recent exaggerations and misrepresentations in some parts of the media of its position on women’s ministry in the church.
“BUCU is not a church, but a student society, so it has never had a formal policy on women’s ministry.
“In recent months, the Executive Committee have been exploring ways in which BUCU can best accommodate members with divergent and strongly held convictions, while expressing our unity as Christian believers.”
It went on to say they will extend speaker invitations to both men and women without exception.
A fairy tale with a happy ending then? A move to limit women’s ability to participate fully in their faith intercepted and the status quo of equality restored?
Except that sadly, it would appear not.
Conservatism, sexism and discrimination seem to have been around since the inception of the group, according to former BUCU member Joel Lewis.
Writing in the Guardian, he suggests that the BUCU has always enforced a ban on women speakers, though it was never explicitly stated before.
Lewis points out that: “The recent statement on the matter issued by BUCU answers only the question that they would like to be asked rather than the ones that they should be asked.
“Of course, it is very welcome that they will invite female speakers – and this is indeed a step forward from the position 15 years ago.
“However the current controversy was not about whether female speakers would be invited, but whether they would be permitted to speak and teach without a male chaperone.
“On this matter the BUCU statement is silent.”
BUCU’s parent organisation, the Universities and Colleges Christian Fellowship, (UCCF), doesn’t enforce explicit viewpoints for either argument.
A recent update to their statement on the situation reads: “UCCF should [sic] like to stress that the choice of any speaker is made by each individual student-run Christian Union.
“UCCF does not have preferred speaker lists or undesirable speaker lists.”
The statement went on to say: “UCCF has staff and students in both camps and everywhere in between; we therefore cannot have a policy of ‘No women speakers’ nor a policy of you must have women speakers.”
And without an official policy in favour of equality, unofficial expressions of discrimination are free to thrive.
The problem is of course, is that it is rather difficult to insist on equality in a university’s Christian organisation, when the Church of England – for example – itself upholds inequality.
After the Church of England’s General Synod voted against women bishops last month, perhaps we are unrealistic to expect BUCU to behave any better.
And if you are not a Christian yourself, does it even matter what the church and its associated organisations get up to?
If you’re a woman – or a man who cares about women being treated fairly – then it absolutely does.
There are young girls being brought up within these certain Christian traditions that tell them they are less capable, less able to reach sensible conclusions and in more need of guidance than the young boys around them.
And just as you don’t have to live in Afghanistan or China to care about the women who do, you equally do not need to hold Christian beliefs yourself to want Christian women to be treated with fairness and respect.
Conversations about bishops and Christian Union policies are not just Christian issues, they are feminist issues too.
And we have a responsibility to fight discrimination and misogyny here as much as anywhere.
That’s the only way for this particular ‘fairy tale’ to have a truly happy ending.
















Male sexist violence and discrimination needs to be positioned as a male issue, not a feminist issue as such. This keeps the responsibility firmly with the users of discriminatory violence, not the victims. We do not position racist violence as a black issue and nor should be refer to sexist violence as a women’s issue, its is a sexists issue. Let’s stop victim blaming and victim responsibility for discriminatory and hate violence used against females.
I´m a Christian woman and I believe in full equality. Actually Jesus and Scriptures, intepreted well , believe in full equality in the home, society and church, this people are hypocrites.
This two Christian webistes promote equality and fight male supremacy:
http://www.cbeinternational.org/
or
http://www.godswordtowomen.org
In case anyone is inetrested in soudn teology, the people who oposse women in ministry or equality in the home, usually read teh Bible literally without context or the original text, or they pick and choose the best verses to make themselves a doctrine…the Bible cannot be handled that way.
Again TRUE CHRISTIANITY makes no discrimination to race or gender…
I know the same Jesus who told us to seek to be the least and the youngest isn’t pleased with some of His children telling others that they aren’t to have a voice.
Women in this denomination should break away and join a truly Christian, Christ-centered, Spirit-driven denomination.
Unfortunately, this sort of thing only represents one faction within conservative Christian circles, but sadly it is one that generates a lot of publicity precisely because it promotes division, disunity and INequality. But this does NOT represent Christianity, nor is it in keeping with the Gospel of Jesus Christ, who came “that they may all be one.” Historically a handful of verses have been minstranslated, misinterpreted, taken out of context and used to promote gender discrimination. This is NOT Christian, nor should it be allowed.
Lewis points out that: “The recent statement on the matter issued by BUCU answers only the question that they would like to be asked rather than the ones that they should be asked.”
“However the current controversy was not about whether female speakers would be invited, but whether they would be permitted to speak and teach without a male chaperone.
“On this matter the BUCU statement is silent.”
Thank you Joel Lewis for calling out BUCU’s obfuscation of the real issue–whether women, simply because they are women, are in need of supervision. The real issue goes much deeper–gender essentialism.
I expected to read events behind this article was taking place in Kabul, or Tehran, or even Riyadh.
But Bristol! In the UK?
These misogynistic people will get short shrift from me.
Seems quite a number of male institutions feel confident in showing their hatred of women’s equality as humans now, whether it be on abortion, right to free speech, speaking in authority, our rights not to be portrayed as whores within the male media etc etc etc – this Christian sect is part of a trend that has been building force in society for the past 20 years, spearheaded by the media’s undermining of women’s equality issues as political correctness rather than just correct.